175
3)
If your needle seems to wander around a lot, you have air in your cooling system. See the
section on filling and bleeding on page 179.
4)
If your needle is above the N, your car is overheating. If your needle is halfway between
the N and the H, your car is severely overheating. And don’t worry about the needle being
on the H; it will never get that far.
Note that these guidelines apply to the XJ-S as configured from the factory -- with the gauge sender located in the right
side thermostat housing. As mentioned above, it’s the left side that is likely to have overheating problems -- which may
explain why trouble occurs when the gauge reads just above the N where any reasonable person would presume it’s still
within normal operating range. If the sender were moved to the left thermostat housing as proposed below, perhaps the
gauge would have to be reading closer to the H to indicate serious trouble.
Believe it or not, it appears that the vertical gauge is actually quite reliable. In many (but not all!) of the reported cases
of the needle being above the N due to problems with the gauge or sender, it was plainly obvious that there were gauge
problems -- often with all four gauges, and sometimes pegging them against the upper end of the gauge seconds after
cold start. More subtle faults in the electrics, such as corroded connections, always seem to cause the needle to read
low (often all four gauges at once -- see page 588) or to not read at all, staying at the C end. A high temp reading that
appears even remotely plausible is usually a cause for concern.
A lot of owners describe the situation when talking about their temp readings, such as how hard they’ve been driving
down the freeway or how hot it is outside today. Unfortunately, such qualifiers are usually an indicator of trouble.
Engine coolant temperature is controlled by the thermostats, and should not vary beyond their control range regardless
of conditions. And their control range (from fully closed to fully open) is pretty tight indeed; it has been described as
“three needle widths” of travel on the gauge. Since the cooling system should always have some margin (excess
cooling capacity) so the thermostats can control the coolant temp, the indication should always be within this control
range. If the gauge ever indicates more than a couple of needle widths above the regular operating temperature with
whatever thermostats are installed -- including reading on the N with 180°F thermostats -- it means that the thermostats
are no longer in control, they are wide open, and it’s absolutely everything the cooling system can do to hold the
temperature indicated. Obviously, if things get just a hair worse -- the outdoor temperature rises a couple of degrees,
one more tube inside your radiator gets plugged up, you sit in traffic a few more minutes, whatever -- the temp is going
to rise some more. Overheating damage is imminent, you need to be taking corrective action now.
The only way “corrective action” would include replacing thermostats is if the thermostats are bad. Merely switching
to colder thermostats is not corrective action; if the cooling system can’t hold 190°F, it won’t be able to hold 180°F
either. Replacing 190°F thermostats with colder thermostats won’t fix anything unless the 190°F thermostats were
defective.
HOW HOT IS TOO HOT? - LATER XJ-S ROUND GAUGE: James Teston says, “I have a '92 with the round
temperature gauge. (Not the barrel gauge)! It looks like this:
C \ N / H
^
|
And this is where the needle stays (Between the N and the right hash mark).”
Steve Gallant says, “My 93 XJR-s with 6.0L engine runs the same regarding temperature -- middle of the N to just
slightly to the right. It has been this way since I purchased the car with 5k miles on it.”
Howard Gladman concurs: “My 95- 6.0L exhibits same reading. Once the the needle reaches about a needle width to
the right of N the Aux fan switches on and the needle stabilizes. 56,000 on the clock and running strong.”
It’s a pretty safe bet that all three of the above cars are running 190°F thermostats. If you’re running colder
thermostats, expect readings farther left than these -- and if you don’t see them, fix your cooling system.